Widescreen Gaming Forum

With all the talk about bad performance numbers for gaming I've been holding off getting Vista. It was interesting to see this commentary about the problem....

http://www.bit-tech.net/columns/2007/02/10/not_enjoying_the_view/1.html

Many people blame Microsoft, saying Vista was not ready, or Vista was late, or Vista was this or that. ........Vista code has been stable and available as a public beta since before my GX2 card was even out. Supposedly, SLI is being marketed as the bleeding edge of game technology - so why on Earth would it not be supported in the bleeding edge of operating systems?

Great read, have to wonder about the top end hardware manufacturers letting down the avid PC Gamer?

nice read with a very interesting discussion forum following it. its nice to see the blame going where it belongs and nicer still to see that an article such as that which publicly calls out third party manufacturers led to immediate change (Nvidia).

just the same though--regardless of where the blame belongs, the result is the same: for a large percentage of serious gamers the operating system is a dud.

The replies on the forum made it to 5 pages really quickly! Its a shame that it turned into a Nvidia bashing forum when really all the peripheral manufacturers should be held accountable.

However, I'm hoping that Nvidia's quick response to the commentary is a good sign for solid performing drivers. The DX10 patch for COH is supposed to come out in March and I'm sure some DX10 games shortly thereafter. Although a system crash spurred me to buy my 8800 card, I would love to see the glory of DX10 :shock: :shock:

Yeah, I stopped reading after the bashing started. Personally I run nVidia and try to stick with it, but this bashing and brand loyalty fanboi stuff is what ruins alot of forums. It's also why I am no longer a member of many of them. It's why I came here. People here are low key, have their head screwed on straight, and understand that not everything we want will come out when we want it. If you go for the cutting edge you have to expect bugs and issues.

I suspect Vista will be a great OS and it's like everything esle. It takes time to iron out bugs. You can't blame the OS or any of the other software developers. They are not gonna commit until they are sure Vista will be a hit, so they aren't gonna develop software for it until they see people are gonna buy it. I think they now know it's the next generation. In about a year this will all smooth out. It's the same thing with every new OS. :)

just for reference, Ati/ AMD have WHQL drivers for vista.

you have Crossfire for Vista too, OpenGL on 64 bit version is lacking.

you also have Blu Ray/ HD-DVD playback on vista too.

and OpenGL works.

why cant nV get SLI working? Microsofts fault? or the same reason they pull support for each chipset when i new one is out?

call me a fanboy, but im sick of people bashing ATi's drivers when they do a hell of a lot more work than nVidia do

_________________
P8Z68-V Pro | 2600K | HR02 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 128GB M4 + 6TB | X-Fi > HD595 | AX850 | Tai Chi | PB278Q | G110 + Deathadder 2013
P8Z77-V | 3570K | Mugen 2 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 500GB | X-750 | Fractal R3 | U2212HM | G110 + G400
P8H77-I | G860 | 4650 | 2x2GB XMS | 320GB | CX500 | Prodigy | T22B350EW | MX518
DC3217IYE | 1x4GB Vengeance | 64GB M4 | TX-42VT20E

They are not gonna commit until they are sure Vista will be a hit, so they aren't gonna develop software for it until they see people are gonna buy it.

Of course people are gonna buy Vista - everyone who buys an off-the-shelf or Dell PC will be getting Vista as standard... it costs more to have XP now, if the places even allow the option! One of my (non-techie) friends just bought a new HP PC, and it has Vista; he's warbling on about how wonderful it is. Then again, he doesn't play games...

Enthusiasts might not flock to Vista in droves - which makes nVidia's reasoning with respect to drivers for the 8800 at the expense of older cards stupid in the extreme because it will be mostly only be enthusiasts who are willing to blow $600 (x2 for SLI) on a GPU...

nVidia's drivers have taken a step back since the introduction of the 90 series. The two biggest plus points for me were the Fixed Aspect Ratio Scaling and (easy) Custom Resolution Addition that ATi didn't have. Now both of those features are broken, nVidia and ATi are on a level playing field with drivers. Especially since ATi have sorted out the (RAM usage) horror of the Catalyst Control Centre with Cat 7.1...

[quote]They are not gonna commit until they are sure Vista will be a hit, so they aren't gonna develop software for it until they see people are gonna buy it.

Of course people are gonna buy Vista - everyone who buys an off-the-shelf or Dell PC will be getting Vista as standard... it costs more to have XP now, if the places even allow the option! One of my (non-techie) friends just bought a new HP PC, and it has Vista; he's warbling on about how wonderful it is. Then again, he doesn't play games...

Enthusiasts might not flock to Vista in droves - which makes nVidia's reasoning with respect to drivers for the 8800 at the expense of older cards stupid in the extreme because it will be mostly only be enthusiasts who are willing to blow $600 (x2 for SLI) on a GPU...

nVidia's drivers have taken a step back since the introduction of the 90 series. The two biggest plus points for me were the Fixed Aspect Ratio Scaling and (easy) Custom Resolution Addition that ATi didn't have. Now both of those features are broken, nVidia and ATi are on a level playing field with drivers. Especially since ATi have sorted out the (RAM usage) horror of the Catalyst Control Centre with Cat 7.1...

you hit the nail on the head. ATi fix stuff with drivers. nVidia break stuff :lol:

_________________
P8Z68-V Pro | 2600K | HR02 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 128GB M4 + 6TB | X-Fi > HD595 | AX850 | Tai Chi | PB278Q | G110 + Deathadder 2013
P8Z77-V | 3570K | Mugen 2 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 500GB | X-750 | Fractal R3 | U2212HM | G110 + G400
P8H77-I | G860 | 4650 | 2x2GB XMS | 320GB | CX500 | Prodigy | T22B350EW | MX518
DC3217IYE | 1x4GB Vengeance | 64GB M4 | TX-42VT20E

Actually I've had more trouble with ATi drivers than any other issue...especially when I was benchmarking. They'd get corrupted every single run where my nVidia drivers would stay stable as a rock and not get corrupted.

I got higher benchmarking scores with nVidia accross the board. None of ATi drivers have ran on my Simulators. On two of them they wouldn't work at all...CTD's as soon as pie screen stopped loading right before the actual simulation opened. I also had alot of the infamous BSOD's.

One of the other problems I noticed on the hardware end was ATi's GPU's have always ran hot. They are massive in size and retain heat badly. They have not gotten into the level of miniatuzation that nVidia has to date. I had a pretty hopped up card with a Rage Fury Pro 3D. That was back in those days. I also got caught up in the All-In-Wonder fiasco. I;ve played with a few crossfire setups on freind's machines also.

Basically the things I have been insterested in nVidia has given me the full package. I've gotten maximum FPS. Good stable drivers. Excellent quality, and cool running GPU's that can clock to insanely high levels. My current 6800GT can go 475/1200 for short bursts during benchmarking. Of course I have modded the cooling somewhat. Before the mods it would do 450/1180. It has stock clocks of 350/1000 for reference. It runs at 46C idle and only gets to 58 for short hard bursts in benchmarks, and will sometimes get to 53 C in actual gaming.

ATi's latest offerings have gotten better, but I don't think they have gotten the performance crown yet. They were close when they released the first cross-fire setups (coded 520R), but the 7800GTX SLi setups still were holding the highest marks.

I suspect the next generation 9000 (?) series cards will still hold the titles. I look for more pixel pipes, even larger amounts of memory, and a next generation GPU. nVidia has pretty much cornered the market on the memory end. The IC's they are using will clock to mad levels.

Drivers are an issue that can be worked on and improved, but once the hardware is developed and made that's pretty much what we have to live with for 6 months. Especially with heat. I can mod cards, but the heat is what ultimately limits max clocks. I still belive nVidia has the crown on the hardware end. I'm certain nVidia will support SLi in Vista, but it's gonna take time.

There's no reason to race to Vista. It just came out. There are security holes. There will be bugs. It's like that with every operating system. It always will be. Personally I'll wait for full support before jumping on it.

On the fixed aspect ratio scaling issue, that is only with certain combinations of monitors/drivers/ and cards. Not all setups are affected. It's not really a driver issue. I belive 7900 and 8800 cards are the only ones affected, and here again is where getting the bleeding edge results in soime issues. That's just the luck of the draw when you get top shelf stuff as soon as it comes out. It's the same with Vista.

Actually I've had more trouble with ATi drivers than any other issue...especially when I was benchmarking. They'd get corrupted every single run where my nVidia drivers would stay stable as a rock and not get corrupted.

I got higher benchmarking scores with nVidia accross the board. None of ATi drivers have ran on my Simulators. On two of them they wouldn't work at all...CTD's as soon as pie screen stopped loading right before the actual simulation opened. I also had alot of the infamous BSOD's.

One of the other problems I noticed on the hardware end was ATi's GPU's have always ran hot. They are massive in size and retain heat badly. They have not gotten into the level of miniatuzation that nVidia has to date. I had a pretty hopped up card with a Rage Fury Pro 3D. That was back in those days. I also got caught up in the All-In-Wonder fiasco. I;ve played with a few crossfire setups on freind's machines also.

Basically the things I have been insterested in nVidia has given me the full package. I've gotten maximum FPS. Good stable drivers. Excellent quality, and cool running GPU's that can clock to insanely high levels. My current 6800GT can go 475/1200 for short bursts during benchmarking. Of course I have modded the cooling somewhat. Before the mods it would do 450/1180. It has stock clocks of 350/1000 for reference. It runs at 46C idle and only gets to 58 for short hard bursts in benchmarks, and will sometimes get to 53 C in actual gaming.

ATi's latest offerings have gotten better, but I don't think they have gotten the performance crown yet. They were close when they released the first cross-fire setups (coded 520R), but the 7800GTX SLi setups still were holding the highest marks.

I suspect the next generation 9000 (?) series cards will still hold the titles. I look for more pixel pipes, even larger amounts of memory, and a next generation GPU. nVidia has pretty much cornered the market on the memory end. The IC's they are using will clock to mad levels.

Drivers are an issue that can be worked on and improved, but once the hardware is developed and made that's pretty much what we have to live with for 6 months. Especially with heat. I can mod cards, but the heat is what ultimately limits max clocks. I still belive nVidia has the crown on the hardware end. I'm certain nVidia will support SLi in Vista, but it's gonna take time.

There's no reason to race to Vista. It just came out. There are security holes. There will be bugs. It's like that with every operating system. It always will be. Personally I'll wait for full support before jumping on it.

On the fixed aspect ratio scaling issue, that is only with certain combinations of monitors/drivers/ and cards. Not all setups are affected. It's not really a driver issue. I belive 7900 and 8800 cards are the only ones affected, and here again is where getting the bleeding edge results in soime issues. That's just the luck of the draw when you get top shelf stuff as soon as it comes out. It's the same with Vista.

i agree with the heat on the ATi cards, why do you think i have water cooling? :lol:

the only thing i can disagree with there is nV drivers and nV memory :P for me at least, the nV drivers have been mostly stable but the nv4disp.dll problem kept striking for a long while. then, when i got my new board (the a8n32sli) it was fine. 1 driver release later then nV pull the plug. you are forced to mess around with the drivers to get the latest stuff. its fine for me as i use dedicated sound card, but its still annoying. and ATi are using GDDR4 as of now with the X1950. they brought stream computing before nV did (and have it working). they just need to sort the heat/ power usage out, their drivers have been fine for me (apart from CCC which is now fixed, aparently :P :P)

_________________
P8Z68-V Pro | 2600K | HR02 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 128GB M4 + 6TB | X-Fi > HD595 | AX850 | Tai Chi | PB278Q | G110 + Deathadder 2013
P8Z77-V | 3570K | Mugen 2 | HD5850 | 2x4GB Vengeance LP | 500GB | X-750 | Fractal R3 | U2212HM | G110 + G400
P8H77-I | G860 | 4650 | 2x2GB XMS | 320GB | CX500 | Prodigy | T22B350EW | MX518
DC3217IYE | 1x4GB Vengeance | 64GB M4 | TX-42VT20E

I've had mixed luck with both ATi and nVidia drivers - it's why I have no brand loyalty, and little patience for out-and-out fanboys who say 'blah-blah is the shiznitz, all otherz suckzors...' (bad 'leet speak' intended)

In the short term, I've had no problems with ATi's drivers, despite moaning about needing manufacturer hacked (four month old) drivers for my new toy (X1950XTX) because ATi hadn't got newer ones on their site that supported the card. In the long term, my only complaint about them is that their linux support isn't terribly good. Never had an ATi driver make my Windows system BSOD, though.

Now for nVidia...

Let me state for the record that I'm currently running three nV cards and three ATi cards, and owned probably another two of each type. So I'm on an even playing field. :) Despite this, nV's tricks with their latest drivers have been pissing me off. Breaking two features that made their drivers for me, was unforgivable. They don't seem to be able to fix it, either. In the longer term, nVidia have had a history of releasing drivers optimised for one specific thing... having to keep swapping drivers because of a particular game I want to play at the time got old fast. ;)

Interesting that you've had ATi drivers corrupt during benching... I've never had that happen to me with any graphics card driver from either side.

Heat... well, right now the X1950XTX and 8800 are pretty much even. R600 is a completely different kettle of fish, though. I just hope ATi don't head back to the 'jet turbine' type cooler...

...

It's the curse of the early adopter, though, isn't it? :(

...

And right now I don't want to have to get a new PSU for either an 8800 or an R600...

...

And I can't find any CrossFire capable Socket 939 boards anywhere... :cry: the damned things have just vanished... (yes, I was contemplating trying out X1950XTX CrossFire...)